An expanding universe
what are the best guess theories for what the universe is expanding into
ChatGPT a dit :
The question of what the universe is expanding into is one of the most mind-bending in cosmology, and surprisingly, the best current answer is: nothing—at least, not in the way we usually imagine space expanding into something.
Here are the best theories and explanations for what this "expansion" means:
🔹 1. Space Itself Is Expanding — Not Into Anything
The prevailing view in modern cosmology (from general relativity and the ΛCDM model) is:
The universe is not expanding into anything. Instead, space itself is stretching.
There's no "outside" of the universe in the standard model. If the universe is infinite, it's becoming more infinite. If it's finite (like the surface of a balloon), it's just growing larger—but there’s still no “outside.”
Analogy: Imagine dots on the surface of a balloon. As you inflate it, the surface expands, and the dots move apart—but the surface doesn’t expand into the air inside the balloon. The surface is all there is in that analogy (2D expanding in a higher-dimension, but only the 2D is "real").
🔹 2. Higher-Dimensional Theories (e.g., Brane Cosmology)
Some speculative theories in string theory and M-theory propose that:
Our universe may be a 3D "brane" embedded in a higher-dimensional space (the "bulk").
In this picture, the universe could technically be expanding into extra dimensions.
These theories are mathematically interesting but currently untestable. There's no observational evidence yet for extra spatial dimensions.
🔹 3. Observable Horizon Limits
From our perspective:
We can only observe part of the universe—the "observable universe"—which is expanding.
It's possible the entire universe is infinite and has always been infinite, so asking "what it's expanding into" is meaningless. It's just getting less dense.
The boundary we talk about (46 billion light-years away) is not an edge—just the limit of what light has had time to reach us from.
🔹 4. Mathematical Models Don't Require an 'Outside'
The equations of general relativity that govern cosmological expansion:
Don’t require embedding in a higher-dimensional space.
Describe internal geometry (curvature, expansion) of spacetime without needing an "external space."
Summary of Theories:
TheoryExpansion IntoNotesStandard ΛCDMNothingSpace itself expands; no external space needed.Brane Cosmology (M-theory)Higher dimensionsHighly speculative; no current evidence.Balloon AnalogyNo real "into"Helpful visualization but breaks down at extremes.Inflation theoryQuantum fluctuationsEarly exponential expansion doesn't imply external space.